Free calculator

Refund impact calculator: what returns really cost you

A return isn't just a lost sale. You've already paid for shipping and ads, you pay to bring the product back, and some of it can't be sold again. Enter your numbers to see how much profit your return rate takes every month.

Inspecting, repacking, support time.
Profit lost to returns$8,850.00
Monthly profit with returns$15,150.00
Monthly profit with no returns
$24,000.00
Share of profit lost
36.9%
Returns per month
150
Extra cost per return
$14.00
Profit lost per return
$59.00
Net margin on kept sales
25.5%
Return rate where profit hits zero
40.7%

Each return costs you $59.00 of profit. Cutting the return rate by 1 point is worth $590.00 a month.

Assumes a full refund on every return; ad spend and outbound shipping are not recovered.

Get your real numbers every day with ProfitFly

Connect Shopify, Meta and TikTok and see your real net profit every day. Free up to 50 orders a month.

Why returns cost more than the refund

When an order is returned you refund the customer, but the ad spend and outbound shipping are gone. On top of that you pay return shipping, someone has to inspect and repack the item, and a share of returned products comes back damaged or unsellable.

So the profit you lose per return is the full sale, minus the product you can put back on the shelf, plus those extra costs.

The formula

Profit lost per return = order value − product cost + return shipping + handling + product cost × % unsellable

Multiply by the number of returns to get the monthly profit lost. The return rate where profit hits zero is your profit per order divided by the profit lost per return.

A worked example

You ship 1,000 orders a month at $70 after tax. Product costs $25, shipping $6 and ads $15 per order, so with no returns you'd make $24 per order, $24,000 a month.

With a 15% return rate you get 150 returns. Each costs $7 of return shipping, $2 of handling and 20% of the $25 product can't be resold ($5): $14 of extra cost. The profit lost per return is $70 − $25 + $14 = $59. That's $8,850 a month, 36.9% of your profit, leaving $15,150. At around a 40.7% return rate you'd make nothing at all.

How to reduce the impact

Most returns come from a mismatch between what the customer expected and what arrived: better size guides, real photos and honest descriptions help more than strict policies. Look at return rate by product, as a few items often cause most returns. Offering store credit or an exchange instead of a refund keeps the revenue.

Common mistakes

Only counting the refunded amount. Assuming every returned product goes straight back into stock. Measuring return rate on all orders while some are still within the return window, which makes recent months look better than they are.

FAQ

How do I calculate my return rate?

Returned orders divided by orders shipped in the same period. Use a period old enough that the return window has closed, or recent months will look too good.

Is a partial refund a return?

For profit it behaves like a smaller return: you lose part of the revenue without getting product back. Lower your average order value or add it separately for a more exact figure.

Should I offer free returns?

Free returns can raise conversion and also raise the return rate. Run the numbers both ways with this calculator: if the extra sales don't cover the extra returns, they're not free for you.

Keep reading